Director Penalty Notices (DPNs) are one of the most impactful tools the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) uses to recover unpaid company tax debts. For directors, the consequences of mishandling a DPN can be devastating, from personal liability to asset seizure and even bankruptcy.
This article shares real-life stories of directors who faced DPNs, highlighting both successes and cautionary tales. By understanding these scenarios, you can better navigate your own challenges and avoid common pitfalls.
Case study 1: Jake’s timely action prevents personal liability
The situation
Jake was the director of a construction company struggling with $180,000 in unpaid PAYG withholding and GST debts. When Jake received a 21-day DPN, he initially panicked, unsure of how to proceed.
The action taken
Jake sought professional advice immediately and was advised to appoint a Small Business Restructuring (SBR) practitioner within the 21-day window. The practitioner helped Jake create a restructuring plan that reduced the company’s debts by 50%.
The outcome
The restructuring plan was approved by creditors, and Jake’s personal liability under the DPN was cleared. By acting quickly, Jake not only avoided financial ruin but also kept his business operational.
Lesson learned
Act immediately: The 21-day window is your best opportunity to avoid personal liability. Seek professional guidance as soon as you receive a DPN.
Case study 2: Laura’s missed deadline leads to bankruptcy
The situation
Laura was the director of a hospitality business that owed $90,000 in GST and superannuation. She received a 21-day DPN but assumed she could negotiate a payment plan with the ATO after the deadline.
The action taken
Unfortunately, Laura didn’t act within the 21-day period. By the time she reached out for help, the DPN had already triggered personal liability for the debts. With no viable options to restructure or liquidate, Laura was forced to use personal savings and assets to cover the debt.
The outcome
Laura’s inability to pay the full amount led to bankruptcy, affecting her credit and professional reputation.
Lesson Learned
Understand the rules: Payment plans with the ATO do not remove personal liability under a DPN. Always act within the prescribed timeframe.
Case study 3: Tom faces a lockdown DPN for late lodgements
The situation
Tom, the director of a marketing firm, was issued a lockdown DPN for $60,000 in unpaid PAYG and superannuation debts. The company had failed to lodge its BAS and SGC returns on time, which triggered immediate personal liability.
The action taken
Since the DPN was a lockdown notice, Tom’s only option was to pay the debt in full. He consulted a financial advisor and refinanced his home to access $40,000. For the remaining $20,000, Tom negotiated a payment plan with the ATO.
The outcome
Tom successfully paid off the liability, but the process strained his finances significantly.
Lesson learned
Lodge BAS, IAS and SGC returns on time: Even if you cannot pay in full, lodging on time ensures debts remain eligible for a 21-day DPN, giving you more options to address liability.
Case study 4: Amanda’s quick response saves her business
The situation
Amanda was the director of a retail company that owed $250,000 in unpaid GST. When she received a 21-day DPN, Amanda immediately sought advice from an insolvency professional.
The action taken
Amanda acted within the 21-day window by appointing a voluntary administrator. The administrator negotiated with creditors, and the company was restructured, reducing its debts by 60%.
The outcome
Amanda’s personal liability was cleared, and her business continued to operate successfully under the new structure.
Lesson learned
Professional help makes a difference: Insolvency professionals can guide you through complex situations and help preserve both your personal finances and your business.
Case study 5: Sarah’s avoidable lockdown DPN
The situation
Sarah was a director of a tech startup that had failed to lodge BAS returns for over a year. When she received a lockdown DPN for $120,000 in PAYG debts, she realised she was personally liable for the entire amount.
The action taken
Sarah worked with an accountant to assess her options. Unfortunately, because the returns were late, the debts could not be reclassified under a 21-day DPN. Sarah had to sell personal investments to cover the liability.
The outcome
Although Sarah resolved the debt, her financial position was severely impacted, delaying her ability to invest in future business ventures.
Lesson learned
Prioritise compliance: Timely lodgement of BAS, IAS and SGC returns prevents debts from becoming lockdown liabilities, offering greater flexibility in addressing the issue.
Key takeaways from these case studies
Act quickly on a 21-day DPN: The 21-day window is critical. Use this time to explore options like Small Business Restructuring or voluntary administration to clear liability.
Stay compliant: Lodging tax returns on time, even without full payment, keeps debts eligible for a 21-day DPN rather than a lockdown DPN.
Seek professional advice early: Insolvency and restructuring experts can help you develop a tailored strategy to address your DPN and minimise personal financial risks.
Understand the consequences of ignoring a DPN: Ignoring the notice or missing deadlines can lead to personal liability, asset seizure, and even bankruptcy.
Plan ahead: If your company is struggling financially, proactive planning can prevent DPNs from being issued in the first place.
FAQs about DPNs
Q: Can restructuring always resolve DPN liabilities?
Restructuring can resolve debts under a 21-day DPN but cannot clear lockdown DPN liabilities, which require full payment.
Q: What happens if I receive multiple DPNs for the same company?
You may receive separate DPNs for PAYG, GST, and SGC debts. Each notice must be dealt with individually.
Q: How can I avoid personal liability altogether?
Staying compliant with lodgement deadlines, paying debts promptly, and seeking early professional advice are the best ways to avoid DPN liabilities.
Final thoughts
These case studies highlight the importance of acting quickly, staying compliant, and seeking professional guidance when dealing with a DPN. Whether you’re facing a 21-day or lockdown DPN, understanding your options and the consequences of inaction can make all the difference.
If you’ve received a DPN or want to proactively manage your company’s tax obligations, contact Business Reset today. Our team specialises in helping directors resolve DPN liabilities and protect their financial futures.
Read next: DPN FAQs: Your questions answered
Previous: DPNs, Liquidation, and Deregistration: What directors must know
Or back to: Director Penalty Notices (DPNs): A Fast-Track Guide for Company Directors