It's nine o'clock at night. A director with a growing ATO debt is scrolling their phone, and, as Jarvis joked, the phone seems to have been listening. The ads roll in: pay out the ATO with your home loan, cut your debt by 80%, cash in your account tomorrow.
Any of those can be the right move. Any of them can also cost a director the business, or the house. What decides it is whether anyone looked at the numbers first.
In our recent webinar, Jarvis Archer of Business Reset was joined by Leo Iermano, a former ATO Director now with SBR Assist, and Giulio Avian, Managing Director of Fundsnational. Between them, they covered all three ways out of an ATO tax debt: repay, refinance or restructure.
Watch the webinar, get the CPD, access the resources
Profit pays the debt, not revenue
Small businesses now owe the ATO around $38 billion. The detail Jarvis kept coming back to was the mix: income tax debt fell by about $1 billion last year, while BAS debt rose by about $4 billion. "If you're not paying your BAS," he said, "it's because you're not making profit, usually."
That's where many directors get caught out. A business turning over $1 million a year feels like it should handle a $350,000 debt. But debt is paid from profit, on top of every new BAS, at a time when interest on tax debt is no longer deductible and the ATO issued around 85,000 director penalty notices (DPNs) in FY25.
Everyone is selling one answer
Attendees were asked what they do when a client can't pay the ATO:
67–70% go for a payment arrangement
15% send them for a restructure
12% haven't acted yet
2% refer them to a finance broker
Only 2% would send a client to a broker, yet Giulio pointed to an ASIC figure showing 63% of small businesses go online or to social media to find funding. Plenty of directors are skipping their adviser entirely. Jarvis compared it to chest pain: you'd see a GP before a surgeon, but with tax debt, directors book straight in with whichever specialist advertised to them.
Repay: three places payment plans fall over
A payment plan is the right first step when the business can afford it. Leo, who spent 28 years at the ATO, sees plans on larger debts fail at three predictable points:
The first BAS after the plan starts. Many clients think the instalment covers future BAS, so suddenly they're paying the old debt and the new tax at once. As Jarvis put it, "you've actually got to pay double."
A history of defaults. A second plan usually can't go through the portal, so it needs a detailed application and a capacity to pay assessment.
A plan rushed in to stop a DPN or a credit listing, before anyone checked the client could keep it up.
Leo also walked through what gets general interest charge (GIC) remitted. His short version: "evidence, evidence, evidence." The longer version, including why a ChatGPT-written submission won't cut it, is in the replay.
Watch the webinar
Hear Leo's tips on getting GIC remitted
Refinance: easy to get, hard to get out of
Nobody goes looking for a loan first, Giulio said. Directors turn to finance when the pressure lands: a DPN, a credit reporting notice, or a payment plan that's been refused. Short-term lenders then look at bank statements, not at whether the business can actually repay.
"The easier it is to get, the harder it is to get out of." Jarvis Archer
The bigger risk is quieter. Refinancing moves company debt onto the director, doing by choice what a DPN does by force, and once it's secured on the house, a restructure can't reduce it. Then there's the cost. A $350,000 tax debt can become around $750,000 over a 25-year loan, and in one file Leo and Giulio worked on, a client received $55,000 from a $75,000 loan and repaid $583 a day.
Hear Giulio on when finance actually works
Restructure: a reset, if it fits
A Small Business Restructure (SBR) can cut the debt while the company keeps trading, with the balance paid over up to two years, interest free. It's also where Jarvis was most candid: many directors who ask for one don't suit it.
Large director loans, unpaid super and ongoing losses can rule it out. So can debt that's already personal through a DPN or a guarantee. For NSW and Victorian builders, the credit file mark means no insurance on new projects until the plan is paid. When it does fit, the option most people miss is to reduce the debt first, then refinance the smaller balance.
Get the full guide to every option, co-written by all three presenters
Two files from the session
A good business, buried by loans
A director rang Business Reset about an SBR, but his ATO debt turned out to be small. The real problem was on his P&L: around $600,000 of online loans from online and short-term lenders, every one personally guaranteed. In 12 months he'd paid about $267,000 in interest and posted a $47,000 loss, in a business that should have made $200,000. Without the equity to refinance, he was facing the loss of both the business and the house.
Three specialists, one rescue
A NSW carpenter came in with around $300,000 of ATO debt, $92,000 of unpaid super and a building licence on the line. The super had to be cleared before an SBR could go ahead, so Giulio lined up finance. Then an ATO credit default blocked the loan.
Clearing it took the accountant, Leo, Giulio and Business Reset working together. The SBR was paid out in full, repayments came down to under $1,000 a month, and the builder's insurance was restored.
See how they cleared the credit default and saved the business
See every option side by side
The session also launched the ATO Debt Options Calculator. Enter the debt, answer a few quick questions about profit and what the business can afford, and it lines the options up on monthly cost, total cost and whether the home is at risk.
Its real value, Jarvis said, is in ruling things out. A client who sees a payment plan would take 17 years from their profit stops hoping for a "magical unicorn outcome" and starts moving.
Compare your client's options in minutes
The bottom line
Jarvis closed on a simple point: any option can be amazing or terrible, depending on the circumstances. A payment plan, a loan and a restructure can each be the right answer. The mistake is choosing one before anyone has diagnosed the problem.
Get the right people around the table early, and a tax debt doesn't have to cost a client the business or the house. Or, in Jarvis's words, the aim is to "dig up, not keep digging down."
Watch the webinar, get the CPD, access the resources
This article is general information only and does not constitute legal or financial advice. Every company's circumstances are different and require individual professional assessment.